I've been thinking for a while about building myself a new desktop. I tend to build and rebuild my machines every month or so, but always with old components. I take things apart and put them back together in different patterns until I get bored of it. Well it's about that time that all of my hardware has surpassed it's useful life in any build pattern I could manage.
So naturally, I've got a few parts coming from Newegg. I deliberated about which parts to buy for a long time. Let me stress that again, a long time. Normally I'm pretty much an impulse buyer when it comes to electronics. This must have been a record for me. It literally took two weeks to decide on this build.
So I've ordered:
-Core i3 540
-Biostar 1156 mobo
-2 x 2GB GSkill DDR3-1333
-150GB 10,000RPM WD Raptor
-Thermaltake Silent 1156 cooler
-and a new SATA DVD-RW drive to top it off
while reusing:
-Antec 300 case -3 x 120mm Antec, 1 x 140mm Antec fans
-PC Power & Cooling 500w Silencer PSU
-ATI HD4770 GPU
In the past I came across as an AMD fanboy. Well let me tell you... That is completely true.
Why Intel this time around? I've been asking myself that for the past two weeks. I think the sheer performance increase over a comparably priced dual or triple core from AMD was what did it. I was initially hovering over the buy button of a Phenom II x2 555 and a water cooler. In fact, the AMD route this time would have been an incredibly cheap upgrade. My current motherboard was flashed to support AM3 Phenom II's all the way up to the new x6. The problem came in the DDR2 my motherboard requires and the power consumption.
"Power consumption? What kind of hippie BS is this?" flew around my head for a while. But it had practical implications as well. Less power consumed means I can feel better leaving the machine on 24/7. Especially if it consumes about what a 70 watt light bulb does when it's at idle like all the reviews show. My low wattage Athlon X2 consumes more than that at idle, and it's designed to consume less power.
Another practical advantage this power consumption crap has is in overclocking. I love overclocking things until they burst. I love the idea of pushing my budget system into monster Core i7 performance territory. Overclocking the x2 4850e to extend its life? Near impossible on my boards. I can't manage to get it past 2.9GHz without voltage increases. At that point it stops being a low wattage processor anyway. Plus, even overclocked my Athlon x2 4850e looks to be about HALF as powerful as a stock Core i3 540. Overclocking a Phenom II x2 555? That's what the water cooler was for. Again though, reviews showed the Core i3 to be a crazy overclocker with performance that blows the Phenom II x2 away.
Then you must be asking, "why not an Athlon x3 or x4 then?" My answer: power consumption. And practicality. I had a quad core. Did I ever use all 4 cores? Never. I was never doing enough at any one time to really push that CPU to its limits. Don't read that the wrong way though. I was constantly aching for more MHz on that quad. None of the applications or games I played could use more than a single core anyway. Even today the proliferation of multi-threading in games is quite small (but growing). That's where a fast dual core with hyper-threading comes in. The best of both worlds? From what I can tell at least.
After all this power consumption nonsense subsided price came into play. The Phenom II x2 555 was hanging around $99 when I was considering it. The Core i3 was lingering at $125. This made the Phenom upgrade choice more attractive from the start. Then the price of the Core i3 on Newegg dropped to $115. A 10 dollar difference made me completely abandon the Phenom upgrade path and reconsider my entire plan.
The Athlon x3 440 sitting at a lowly <$80 price only muddied the waters for a short time, as the 95w TDP kept creeping back.
So my total price went from a smidge under $180 for a Phenom + water cooler to $325 for a CPU, mobo, RAM, cooler, and optical drive. The WD Raptor was actually free, but that's for later. For this price I'm getting a fast dual core with HT and a sky to overclock up to, a cooler to enable said overclock, and new fancy RAM with room on the mobo to upgrade. Finally, I'm hoping this will enable my HD4770 to reach its full potential.
Is the expectation of far superior system performance worth the extra cash? I hope so. I've been trying to justify it since I ordered Saturday. Parts should be in this week. I hope I'm right.